Maddie Poppe Squashes Strange Cedar Falls Rumor

When you're public figure like American Idol winner Maddie Poppe, there are bound to be some strange rumors that come up over time. One of the weirdest things to ever be said  about the Clarksville native involves a brownie, a Cedar Falls restaurant, and her sarcastic boyfriend.

Get our free mobile app

Poppe has been with her boyfriend, fellow Idol alum Caleb Lee Hutchinson for several years now. The pair got together during their season on the hit singing competition show in 2019, and announced their relationship during the season 16 finale.

One of the things that Poppe seems to truly love about her boyfriend is his sense of humor, and how "extremely sarcastic" he can be sometimes.  It's proven to get them both in trouble every now and then, but one instance in Cedar Falls still has her getting glares and whispers to this day.

The duo went out for dinner at the Cedar Falls Texas Roadhouse one evening. According to Maddie, one of the waitresses went up to the couple as they were eating and asked for a picture.

Before the young singer had a chance to say anything, Caleb jokingly chimes in with...

"Only if you can give us a free brownie!"

Poppe laughed it off before agreeing to take the picture. However, the Georgia native wouldn't let up.

"He kept going with the joke," his girlfriend tried to explain. "This rumor still haunts me to this day!"

Poppe has no hard feelings toward the staff there. The singer has personal ties to the Cedar Falls eatery, and apparently, people still remember this encounter nearly four years later.

"I do not ever demand free things because these are the rumors that get started," the singer says about the strange 'Browniegate.'

"Sometimes you catch people on a bad day," Poppe points out "you can't be happy all the time."

From the looks of the star's social media, it looks like she has some new music on the way. No word on when fans should expect the new music though.